Traffic:   0 Incidents
Weather: 72°F Go
  09:42pm EDT, 07/24/08
Search:    wtic.com  Web  Audio
McCain Castigates Obama on Judges; Cites Conn. Case


WINSTON-SALEM, N.C. (AP) - Republican John McCain criticized Democratic rival Barack Obama for voting against John Roberts as U.S. chief justice, reaching out to the Christian right on one of their chief concerns: the proper role of judges in government.

Conservatives contend that federal judges have upset the constitutional balance of power among the courts, the Congress and the presidency by making far-reaching decisions, such as one in 2005 that let cities seize people's homes to make way for shopping malls.

``My nominees will understand that there are clear limits to the scope of judicial power, and clear limits to the scope of federal power,'' McCain said Tuesday in a speech at Wake Forest University.

McCain, the eventual GOP nominee, promised to appoint judges in the mold of Roberts and Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito, saying they would interpret the law strictly to curb the scope of their rulings. While McCain didn't mention abortion, the far right understands that such nominees would be likely to limit or perhaps overturn the Roe v. Wade decision that legalized abortion.

Obama, on the other hand, voted against Roberts and Alito. So did Obama's rival, Hillary Rodham Clinton, but McCain focused on Obama.

``Senator Obama in particular likes to talk up his background as a lecturer on law, and also as someone who can work across the aisle to get things done,'' McCain said. ``But ... he went right along with the partisan crowd, and was among the 22 senators to vote against this highly qualified nominee.''

In response, Obama's campaign said McCain would pick judges who would threaten abortion rights as well as McCain's own campaign finance reform bill.

``What's truly elitist is to appoint judges who will protect the powerful and leave ordinary Americans to fend for themselves,'' Obama spokesman Tommy Vietor said.

The Arizona senator said his role models interpret the law strictly, paying attention to what lawmakers intended, as opposed to ``activist'' judges who, by striking down statutes or court decisions, make laws rather than interpret them. ``Activist'' is a term conservatives use pejoratively to criticize liberal justices.

McCain did not spare his own party, pointedly criticizing opinions written by Republican appointees, Supreme Court justices John Paul Stevens and Anthony Kennedy. He didn't name the justices but used their writings to make his case against judicial activism.

McCain spoke derisively of Kennedy's 2005 majority opinion banning executions for killers younger than 18. McCain said the opinion contained ``airy constructs ... as poor substitutes for clear and rigorous constitutional reasoning.''

Kennedy recently defended his reasoning in the case, decided on a 5-4 vote, saying it was ``a matter of interpretation of our own Constitution.''

In the Connecticut private property case McCain mentioned, Kelo v. New London, the Supreme Court chose to defer to local officials rather than impose their own will from afar. Justice John Paul Stevens, in his majority opinion, wrote of the court's ``long-standing policy of deference to legislative judgments in this field.''

McCain wasn't in the Senate when Stevens became a justice, but he voted for Kennedy's nomination by President Reagan in 1988.

For a moment Tuesday, McCain appeared confused about where he was, saying, ``I appreciate the hospitality of the students and faculty of West Virginia,'' then correcting himself to say Wake Forest as the audience laughed.

By speaking about judges, McCain offered an olive branch to the Christian right, which has been deeply suspicious of McCain. He has clashed with its leaders and worked against them on issues like campaign finance reform. He also joined the ``Gang of 14,'' a group of senators _ seven Republicans and seven Democrats _ who avoided a showdown over judges by agreeing to preserve the minority party's right to block President Bush's nominees with the filibuster.

Despite his rocky relations with the right, McCain's record on their top priorities _ cultural issues like abortion _ is very conservative.

While he did say once in 1999 that Roe v. Wade should not be overturned, that amounted to a blip in an otherwise unbroken record of opposing abortion rights for women. McCain repeatedly has voted against federal funding for abortion and has opposed federal Medicaid funds for abortion even in cases of rape or incest.

Several conservative activists said they liked McCain's speech.


Associated Press
Post this article to:
 
 
Print Page Email This Page
Best Local News On The Web
 
 
ADVERTISEMENT
 
 
 
 
Top News
Amann Forms Prison Assault Task Force
Teen Dies, Mob Beats Up Driver In New Haven Crash
Attorney Pleads Guilty To Bank Fraud
Inmate's Death Ruled A Suicide
Conn. AG Proposes New Environment Energy Panel
Jordanian National Sentenced In Bribery Scheme
Police Say Man Burglarized His Parents' Home
Judge Says Boat Operator Was Not Drunk
Stolen Jewett City Fire Truck Recovered
DOT: Emergency Repairs Need For New Haven Bridge
Getaway Driver In Robbery Spree Gets 12 Years
New Bedford Man Convicted Of Murder
Number Of Abortions On The Rise In Connecticut
List Of Connecticut Sex Offenders Tops 5,000
Two Lawyers Admit Hiding Source of Contribution to Man Now Running for Congress
Suspect in Coventry Shooting Found Dead at Garner Prison
Union: Pratt & Whitney Seeks Buyouts
12-Year-Old Boy Charged With Raping Another Child
Police Identify Kayaker Who Drowned In Ridgefield
Group Says Gas Law Lowered Prices Statewide
Affidavit Says Pool President Knew Of Safety Law
Inmate Found Dead In Apparent Suicide
Teen Asks Rell For Help In Alleged Racial Beating
Fatal Shooting Bridgeport's 10th Homicide Of Year
Would-Be Trooper Gets Prison For Sexual Assault
Torrington Lawyer Given Prison For Client Theft
Hartford Police Arrest Shooting Suspect
Stinging Jellyfish Move Into Long Island Sound
Lieberman Speaks To Controversial Pastor's Group
No Consensus on How to Help State Residents with High Energy Costs
Plea in Bridgeport in International 'Phishing' Scheme
Advisory Board Recommends Landmark Status for Coltsville
Prosecutor Says Police Shooting Was Justified
Dive Team Finds Body Of Kayaker In Ridgefield
Rell Unveils 'New' Idea For Cost Savings
Lawmakers Debating Gas, Energy Prices Again
GE, Abu Dhabi Investment Company Agree To Partnership
NAACP Seeks Federal Probe In Ansonia
Labor Board Backs UAW In Foxwoods Labor Dispute
Bridgeport Board Considers Plan For Movie Studios
Hartford Man Sentenced For Running Heroin Ring
Cheshire Inmate Has Brief Taste Of Freedom
Bridgeport Shipyard Seeks Bankruptcy Protection
Wreck Shut Down I-84 Westbound In Waterbury Monday
Rell Says Fiscal Year Ends In Surplus
Lieberman To Speak To Controversial Pastor's Group
Midwest Airlines Cancels Direct Flights To Milwaukee
Swimming Pool President Charged in Boy's Drowning
DEP Says Program To Increase Lobster Size OK
Man Shot In Bridgeport While Riding Motorcycle
Bid To Get Rid Of Bugs Results In New Haven Fire
Woman Accused Of Trying To Cut Power To Ex-Boss
Three Dead in Weekend Hartford Incidents
Westport Officers Wound Domestic Violence Suspect
DEP Seeks Witnesses in Candlewood Lake Crash
Survivor Struggles To Carry On Slain Family's Legacy
Food Pantries See Surge In Demand
School Lunch Prices On Rise
Thousands Turn Out For Petit Race
Police: Westport Officers Shoot Suspect
Two Dead, Three Injured in Boating Accident
Mashantuckets Facing Credit Downgrading
Mansfield Woman Charged in Death of 7-Month-Old
Waterbury, St. Mary's Hospitals seek permission to continue heart surgeries
Probate Court Administrator Resigns
Math, Writing, Science Scores Up in CAPTs
CBS Files Appeal over Connecticut Marine Interview
Gas Prices Hit $4.37 a Gallon in Conn.
Motorists Report Windows Shot Out on I-691
Man Gets 25 Years in Prison in Girl's Kidnapping
Cosby Speaks to Packed House in Hartford
FOI Commission: New Haven ID Holders' Names, Addresses, Photos Secret
Environmentalists Criticize Rell
Man Robbed Buying Drugs Calls Cops, is Arrested
Woman Sent To Prison For Role In UConn Death
Former DOT Engineer Pleads Guilty to Bribery
Judge again delays start of Darien priest's prison term
Freed US Hostage Denounces Colombian Rebels
Receiver Named for Four Haven Homes
Conn. AG Calls for Changes to Video Game Ratings
Teen Charged with Shooting Baby with Paint Ball
CRRA Makes it Easier to Recycle Trash
Lobby Group Seeks Lower Energy Costs for Seniors
Man Dies in New Milford Condo Fire
Stamford Police Find Bomb Materials in Home
Two Motorcyclists Die in Crash on I-91
Connecticut July 4th Weekend Marked by Bell Ringing, Fireworks
Judge Approves Split of Haven Healthcare Chain
GE Aviation Buys Czech Turboprop Engine Maker
No Prison Time for Pfizer Employee Embezzlement
State Offering $50K Reward in Milford Homicide
Poll: Rell's Popularity Drops
Man Dies, Son Injured in Voluntown Pond
Regulators Give CL&P OK to Boost Electricity Rates
Auriemma Signs 5-year, $8-million Contract
Hartford Courant plans job cuts
Puppy Stolen, Cats Missing After Meriden Humane Society Burglary
Connecticut Man Sentenced in NY Kidnapping Conspiracy
House Bids Farewell to Dyson
Police Seek Public's Help in Solving String of Sexual Assaults
Police, OSHA Investigate Worker's Death at Derby Business
Feds: Bombing Suspect Had Van Filled with Explosives
Hamilton Sundstrand Loses Out on Space Suit Contract
Special Session Continues at State Capitol
New Haven Police Investigate Double Homicide
Court Rules in Southbury Case
Bail Bondsmen Sentenced for Bribery Conspiracy
Man Charged with Killing Black Bear
Flags Lowered after Waterbury Soldier Dies in Iraq
Union Goes to Court Seeking Permit to Protest
Skier Settles Lawsuit over Steroid Flap
Waterbury's Holy Land Cross Dismantled
Hop Brook Lake CritterCam
Friend of Connecticut poets and writers has died
Hartford AIDS Organizations Hold Annual Fundraiser
Sex Assault Suspect's Mother Testifies on Possible Bond Violation Alibi

Due to delays in the WTIC streaming broadcast, listeners to WTIC online
stream may not be able to participate in any WTIC conducted on-air contests.