Traffic:   1 Incidents
Weather: 28°F Go
  12:16pm EST, 11/22/08
Search:    wtic.com  Web  Audio
After the decision was announced, lead plaintiffs Elizabeth Kerrigan and Joanne Mock spoke in Hartford with their sons, Carlos and Fernando. Photo by WTIC's Matt Dwyer.

State High Court to Release Gay Marriage Ruling

HARTFORD, Conn. (AP) _ A sharply divided Connecticut Supreme Court ruled Friday that gay couples have the right to get married, saying legislators did not go far enough when they approved same-sex civil unions that were identical to marriages in virtually every respect except the name.

The 4-3 ruling will make Connecticut the third state, behind Massachusetts and California, to allow same-sex marriages, decisions that in all cases were made by the highest state court. The decision marks the first time that a court rejected civil unions as an alternative to granting gay couples the right to marry.

Californians will vote next month on a ballot measure that would reinstate the gay-marriage ban, but Connecticut's governor and attorney general said there is little chance of a similar challenge to Friday's ruling.

``The Supreme Court has spoken,'' said Gov. M. Jodi Rell, a Republican who opposes same-sex marriage. ``I do not believe their voice reflects the majority of the people of Connecticut. However, I am also firmly convinced that attempts to reverse this decision _ either legislatively or by amending the state Constitution _ will not meet with success.''

Same-sex weddings are expected to begin in Connecticut in less than a month. Out-of-staters will be eligible, but few other states are likely to recognize the unions.

The ruling was thrilling for the plaintiffs, eight couples who sued in 2004 after they tried to get wedding licenses.

``I can't believe it. We're thrilled; we're absolutely overjoyed. We're finally going to be able, after 33 years, to get married,'' said plaintiff Janet Peck of Colchester.

Peck said that when the decision was announced, she and her partner, Carole Conklin, started crying and hugging while juggling excited phone calls from her brother and other relatives and friends.

``We've always dreamed of being married,'' she said. ``Even though we were lesbians and didn't know if that would ever come true, we always dreamed of it.''

A year after the suit was filed, Connecticut's General Assembly approved a civil union law that gave same-sex couples the same rights as married couples. At the time, no other state had granted so many rights to gay couples without being ordered to do so by a court, but the plaintiffs declined to drop their lawsuit and said they wanted full marriage rights.

In the majority opinion, Supreme Court Justice Richard N. Palmer wrote that denying marriage to same-sex couples would create separate standards.

``Interpreting our state constitutional provisions in accordance with firmly established equal protection principles leads inevitably to the conclusion that gay persons are entitled to marry the otherwise qualified same sex partner of their choice,'' Palmer wrote.

Three justices issued separate dissenting opinions.

Justice Peter T. Zarella wrote that he believes there is no fundamental right to same-sex marriage, and that the court's majority failed to discuss the purpose of marriage laws, which he said is to ``privilege and regulate procreative conduct.''

Zarella added, ``The ancient definition of marriage as the union of one man and one woman has its basis in biology, not bigotry. If the state no longer has an interest in the regulation of procreation, then that is a decision for the legislature or the people of the state and not this court.''

Senior Associate Justice David M. Bordon cited Connecticut's civil union's law passed in 2005 and said there is no conclusive evidence that civil unions are inferior to marriages.

``It is simply too early to know this with any reasonable measure of certitude,'' Borden wrote.

The ruling cannot be appealed to federal courts because it deals with state constitutional issues, Attorney General Richard Blumenthal said.

The ruling overturns a decision from New Haven Superior Court. It becomes effective Oct. 28, and weddings are expected to begin within days after the lower court holds a hearing to implement the high court's ruling.

The Family Institute of Connecticut, a political action group that opposes gay marriage, called the ruling outrageous.

``Even the legislature, as liberal as ours, decided that marriage is between a man and a woman,'' said executive director Peter Wolfgang. ``This is about our right to govern ourselves. It is bigger than gay marriage.''

Getting a constitutional amendment banning gay marriage on Connecticut's ballot would require the approval of three-quarters of the General Assembly _ a highly unlikely prospect, with both houses controlled by Democrats sympathetic to same-sex marriage.

A gay marriage ban also could be approved by a constitutional convention. Connecticut law requires a state referendum every 20 years asking whether it should hold a convention at which delegates would consider rewriting anything in the state's Constitution. The referendum happens to be scheduled for next month, but there is little, if any, appetite for such a move among state leaders, regardless of party.

State Rep. Michael Lawlor, chairman of the legislature's Judiciary Committee, said he expects the General Assembly to pass a gay marriage law next year codifying the Supreme Court ruling.

``It's important that both the legislature and the court weigh in,'' he said. ``The court is saying that it's a constitutional requirement that marriage should be equally available to gays and straights and the legislature should weigh in saying whether or not it's constitutionally required, it's the right thing to do.''

The couples who sued said the state's marriage law violated their constitutional rights to equal protection and due process, denying them the financial, social and emotional benefits of marriage enjoyed by heterosexual couples.

The vast majority of states do not allow gay marriage. Voters in 27 states have taken the extra step of approving constitutional amendments to reinforce that prohibition.

Civil unions and a similar arrangement, known as domestic partnerships, are offered to same-sex couples in Vermont, New Jersey, New Hampshire, Oregon, Hawaii, Maine, Washington and the District of Columbia.


Post this article to:
 
 
Print Page Email This Page
Best Local News On The Web
 
 
ADVERTISEMENT
 
 
 
 
Top News
Two Officers Hit at DUI Checkpoint, Driver Charged with DUI
Fatal Crash on I-84 in Southington
UConn Men Top La Salle 89-81
UConn Health Center, Hartford Hospital Announce Merger Plans
Paul Newman Leaves Assets to Wife, Foundation
Connecticut-based Save the Children Seeks Education for Kids in War Zones
Groton Sub Base Says Goodbye to Nuclear Research Boat
Dodd Hears from Connecticut Auto Industry
Conn. First to Enact Olive Oil Standards
UConn Women Rout San Diego St, 99-55
Conn. Jobless Rate Reaches 6.5 Percent
Bradley to Offer Security 'Family Lanes'
Car Dealers Ask State to Reduce or Lift Sales Tax
State's Budget Deficit Surges Nearly Quarter Billion $ in Last Month
Hartford Man Accused of Wearing Army Uniform to Carry Out Check Fraud
Stabbing Victim Dies of Injuries
Former Bridgeport Mayor Seeks New Trial, Charging Misconduct by Prosecutors
40 Year Sentence Expected in Stabbing Death at Upscale Hotel
Rell Proposal Aimed at Fighting Foreclosures
Fake Soldier Arrested Arrested Trying to Cash Fraudulent Check
One Person Is Dead After Trailer Fire in Vernon
Two in Good Condition after Light Plane Crash
Woman Accused of Starving Dog Headed for Trial
Police Investigate Break-ins of 125 Units at Public Storage
Teacher's Attorney Says They've Reached Deal with Board on Porn Allegations
Police Investigate Fatal Shooting
Fugitive Sentenced to 15 Years
Volunteer Firefighter Charged with 10 Counts of Arson
Himes Meets Conn. Delegation on Capitol Hill
Lieberman in Sit-Down Interview with CBS's Katie Couric
Developer's Father Charged with Cash Structuring Conspiracy
Dodd Says Possibility of Federal $$$ Deal for Carmakers is 'Remote'
DeLuca Seeks Reimbursement; Says Lawmakers Attacked Him to Further Their Careers
Pentagon Defends Bridge Funding for F-22 While Future of Program is Decided
Attorney for Suspect in Brother's Death Says Case Was Tragic Accident
United Way Ends '08 Campaign With Record Collection Despite Economy
Student Stabbed on Woodland Street; Friends Carry Him to ER
Attorney in DUI Case Says Breath Tests are Discriminatory
CVH Escapee Charged with Mailing Anthrax Hoax Letters
State's College Enrollment Hits Record High for Seventh Straight Year
Governors Ask for Emergency Job Re-Training Money for Financial Services Workers
Groundskeeper Charged with Cruelty in Beating Death of Skunk
DPUC Hearing Focuses on AT&T Customer Service
Larson Elected Fourth Ranking Democrat in U.S. House
Norwich Police Make Arrest in Armed Robbery
Some of Connecticut's Deficit Woes Tied to Market
Sex Offender Charged in New Haven Rape
Travelers Championship Announces Charitable Donations from 2008 Tournament
Police Locate Man Sought for Questioning in Southbury Shooting
Edsall Says He's Not Interested in Syracuse Coaching Job
Stafford Child Pornography Suspect Appears in Court
Shelton Developer Charged with Bribery
McCain Backer Lieberman May Keep Committee Chair
UConn Kicker Teggert Named Big East Special Teams Player of Week
Huskies Now 7 and 3 with 39-14 Defeat of Syracuse
23 Points for Thabeet as He Leads Huskies to 81-55 Defeat of Western Carolina
Fire Engine Crash in 'Quiet Corner'
New Defendant in 2 Decade Old Attack Charged, Arraigned
Mononucleosis Sidelines UConn Freshman for Early Part of Season
Police report: Officers Reasonable Breaking up Off-campus Wesleyan Party
Secretary of the State's Office Begins Audit of Election Results
Suspect Returned to Connecticut in 'Cold Case' That Sent Wrong Man to Jail
Avon Man Gets 3 Years in Jail for Child Porn
Rell: Connecticut Faces Huge Budget Deficits
Dodd Supporting Lieberman in Democratic Fight
Gay Couples Starting to Marry in Connecticut
Connecticut Observes Veterans Day
PHOTOS Veterans Day 2008 in Connecticut
Another Arrest in DMV License Scam
Greenwich Man Appeals Reptile-possession Conviction
Army Corps of Engineers Narrows List of Possible Sites for Training Facility
Avian Flu Tests Continue, Including on Hartford-West Hartford Line
Seventieth Anniversary of Kristallnact Observed in Hartford
Tentative Deal in EB Contract Talks
Connecticut Children's Book Fair Back for Seventeenth Annual Edition
New Britain Healthcare Facility Pays 222K Over Banned Nurse
Rev. Wright Comes to Connecticut
Hamden Police Say They Intercepted an Expensive Contraband Delivery
Charges Dropped Against Two Men in Norwich Killing
UConn Defeats Division II AIC 83-58 in Exhibition at Gampel
As State Faces Deficits, State Agencies Discuss Possible Spending Changes
Hartford Police Name Shooting Victim
Preservationists Watching Situation at Goodwin Hotel in Downtown Hartford
Jet Fuel Spill at BDL
Democrats Sweep Connecticut Congressional Races
UConn's Maya Moore Named Preseason All-American
Conn. Airman Missing from World War II Identified
Prison System Escapee Sought in Hartford Bank Heists
Gay Marriages to Begin in Conn. on Nov. 12
Death Row Inmate Asks Judge to Appoint New Lawyer
Connecticut Expects 90 Percent Turnout Tuesday
State Supreme Court Chief Justice Rejects Challenge to Obama's Citizenship
Mashantucket Pequots, Unionized Casino Dealers Say They Will Start Negotiations
Ghosts and Goblins Out and About This Halloween
22 Caliber Bullets Found at High School, Thompson Schools Complex Locked Down
Regulators: Heart Center of Greater Waterbury Fails to Submit Some Paperwork
Funeral for Ashford Boy Killed Firing Uzi
Student Found With Loaded Gun at Weaver High School in Hartford
Demonstrators: Violence a Problem in Hartford and Suburbs
Quinnipiac Professor Helps in Restoration of Mummies in New Guinea
State Police Identify Ellington Crash Victim
Tweed Airport Wins Suit to Build Safety Areas
Connecticut Child Killed in Submachine Gun Shooting at Mass. Gun Fair
Pickup Truck Driver Accused of Dragging Dog
Disabled veterans move into new healthcare facility in Rocky Hill
Dodd Says Mortgages Subject of Ethics Panel
Connecticut Couple Killed in New Hampshire Highway Crash
UAW, Casino Agree to Negotiate
VIDEO Rell: Legislature's Help Needed for Deficit-Fighting Measures
Fire Strikes Hartford Laundry Business
Requests for Heating Help Skyrocket
Report: UConn Freshman Miles Expelled
Fedele Heading to China
DSS Says Wyman Audit a Conflict
Board of Ed. Approves New Graduation Requirements
Bailout Passes Senate, House Foes Soften
Greenwich Ponders a Pool for Residents Only
New Sunshine Law Poses Problems for Local Boards
Former DOT Worker Pleads Guilty to Stealing I-Beam
Rowland Prosecutor Dannehy to Investigate Firings of U.S. Attorneys
Screen Legend Paul Newman Dead at 83
Liberty Beat Sun to Advance to Conference Finals
Connecticut ACLU Says Inmate Being Force Fed
Rell Says Projected Budget Deficit Tops $300M
Wallingford Man Struck, Killed by Big Rig
Stamford Police Say Deaths Were Murder-Suicide
College Dance Professor Resigns over Padded Resume
Rell Orders Security Review after UConn Rapes
CL&P Sends Crews to Upstate New York to Help with Power Restoration
OSHA Proposes $117,000 in Fines on Plainville Firm
State Agency Seeks Penalty against CNG
Connecticut Court Upholds Medicaid Fraud Penalties
Hartford Extends Emergency Curfew
Man Gets 16 Years in Prison in Sex Slave Case
Inmate Runs from Van, Caught Moments Later
PHOTOS Mystic Aquarium caring for Chicago aquarium's whales and dolphins
UConn Men's Basketball Announces 2008/2009 Schedule
UConn Announces Women's Basketball Schedule
Hartford North Meadows Pumping Station Photos
PHOTO GALLERY Connecticut Civil War Monument Unveiled
Food Donations from Home Gardeners Banned
Special Probation in East Haven Fetus Assault Case
Union Goes to Court Seeking Permit to Protest
Skier Settles Lawsuit over Steroid Flap
Waterbury's Holy Land Cross Dismantled
Hop Brook Lake CritterCam
Friend of Connecticut poets and writers has died

Due to delays in the WTIC streaming broadcast, listeners to WTIC online
stream may not be able to participate in any WTIC conducted on-air contests.