Traffic:   4 Incidents
Weather: 70°F Go
  11:46am EDT, 08/28/08
Search:    wtic.com  Web  Audio
Study: Racial Bias, Randomness Mar Conn. Death Penalty Cases

HARTFORD, Conn. (AP) - Lawyers for state death row inmates have released a study that concludes minorities are disproportionately sentenced to die for their crimes in Connecticut, and decisions to seek the death penalty are often arbitrary.

The findings of the study, led by a Yale Law School professor, are disputed by the state, and become the latest chapter in a complicated legal battle that began 13 years ago. Seven of the state's nine death row inmates have been challenging their sentences, saying there is racial and geographic discrimination in the use of the death penalty.

The issue will be debated at an unusual state Superior Court hearing Thursday and Friday in the gymnasium at Northern Correctional Institution in Somers, with the seven inmates scheduled to take part. Judge Stanley T. Fuger Jr. is scheduled to hear arguments on the state's motion to dismiss the inmates' court cases.

Yale Law School professor John J. Donohue III, who oversaw the study, said one of the most surprising findings is that the death penalty is often not sought for crimes that are more violent and disturbing than ones where lethal injection is pursued.

``There was basically no rational system to explain who got the death penalty,'' Donohue said Tuesday. ``It really is about as random a process as you can possibly construct.''

Over the past year, researchers reviewed 207 murder cases dating back to the early 1970s that were eligible for death penalty prosecution. Donohue said 60 percent of the defendants were minorities and 40 percent were white, numbers that conflict with the percentages in the general population.

Among the other findings in Donohue's 128-page report:

_ Black defendants receive death sentences at three times the rate of white defendants in cases where the victims were white.

_ Killers of white victims are treated more severely than people who kill minorities, when it comes time to decide the charges.

_ Minorities who kill whites receive death sentences at higher rates than minorities who kill minorities.

Of the inmates on death row, four are black, three are white and two are Hispanic.

Senior Assistant State's Attorney John Massameno, who will argue the state's case this week, disputed the report's findings and the inmates' allegations.

``There probably is no category of prosecution in the state of Connecticut that is more carefully and circumspectly pursued than capital litigation,'' Massameno said. ``The notion that it's arbitrary and capricious ... will be overwhelmingly refuted, nor is it racially discriminatory.''

Massameno said the study that was just released by the inmates' lawyers was actually the second one they commissioned, and it's not clear what the first report concluded. It was never released.

Another recent study, in which Ohio State University examined death row cases in 16 states, found that blacks who kill whites are more likely than other killers to be sentenced to death, and more likely to be executed. That study also showed that blacks receiving death sentences for killing nonwhites are less likely to be put to death than other death row inmates.

The Connecticut inmates' legal arguments date back to 1994, when condemned killer Sedrick Cobb asked the state Supreme Court for a chance to study the state's administration of the death penalty. Cobb was sentenced to lethal injection for the killing of a 23-year-old woman in 1989.

Several other death row inmates also went to court with issues of race and fairness, leading the state Supreme Court in 2003 to consolidate all the cases into one habeas corpus proceeding, another avenue for appeals that allows inmates to challenge their incarceration.

This week's hearings are part of that proceeding.

The state's last execution was in 2005, when serial killer Michael Ross, who was white, was put to death by lethal injection. It was the first execution in New England in more than 45 years. Ross declined to be part of the habeas corpus challenge.

 


Associated Press
Post this article to:
 
 
Print Page Email This Page
Best Local News On The Web
 
 
ADVERTISEMENT
 
 
 
 
Top News
Toddler Wounded in Gun Accident in Jewett City
Mystic Firefighter Faces New Arson Charges
Assault Rifles, Body Armor Seized in Hartford Gun Investigation
UConn-Hofstra Preview
Former Husky Forward Abrosimova Signs With Connecticut Sun
Federal Judge Denies Schaghticoke Tribal Recognition
New Haven Shooting Victim Identified as UConn Senior
Second Human West Nile Case Reported in State
Inmate Pleads Not Guilty in Attack on Guards
Body of 73 Year Old Man Found at Old Saybrook Cottage; Police Investigate
Danbury Man Sentenced for Repeated Sexual Assaults of Teen
Percentage of Uninsured Drops in Connecticut
Judge Rules in Schaghticoke Legal Fight for Federal Recognition
Victims in Drive-By Shooting Identified
Bristol Police Investigate Suspicious Device
Lieberman Says He Doesn't Expect to Be Chosen GOP VP Candidate
Former UConn Recruit Says She 'Burned Out' on Basketball
Two Dead in Hartford Shooting
Former Governor's Stepson Dies at Age 23
Shays Cites Obama, McCain in Congressional Re-election Ad
Some Hartford Council Members Want Second Chance at Allocating Library Money
PHOTO GALLERY Connecticut Civil War Monument Unveiled
Civil War Monument Unveiled in Hartford, Headed to Vicksburg
Connecticut Report: More 'English Language Learners' in Schools
Hartford Youth Curfew Going into Effect
Three Dozen Protest Tropic Thunder in Middletown
Food Donations from Home Gardeners Banned
Special Probation in East Haven Fetus Assault Case
Waterbury Heart Center Fighting for Life
Vernon Couple Arrested for Alleged Child Beatings
Six Injured, One Dead in North End Shootings Following Parade
Motocross Rider Dies of Injuries After Stafford Crash
Report: DOT Costs on The Rise
Regulators Order CNG to Credit Customers
Congress Offers Some Relief from Property Taxes
State Issues Annual Water System Violation Report
Report: Scientist Linked To Anthrax Attacks Commits Suicide
Massachusetts House Vote: Allow Out-of-state Gay Couples to Marry
Woodbury Jazz guitarist Joe Beck dead at 62
Police: Westport Officers Shoot Suspect
Two Dead, Three Injured in Boating Accident
Mashantuckets Facing Credit Downgrading
Mansfield Woman Charged in Death of 7-Month-Old
Probate Court Administrator Resigns
Math, Writing, Science Scores Up in CAPTs
CBS Files Appeal over Connecticut Marine Interview
Gas Prices Hit $4.37 a Gallon in Conn.
Motorists Report Windows Shot Out on I-691
Cosby Speaks to Packed House in Hartford
Environmentalists Criticize Rell
Man Robbed Buying Drugs Calls Cops, is Arrested
Former DOT Engineer Pleads Guilty to Bribery
Freed US Hostage Denounces Colombian Rebels
Receiver Named for Four Haven Homes
Conn. AG Calls for Changes to Video Game Ratings
Teen Charged with Shooting Baby with Paint Ball
CRRA Makes it Easier to Recycle Trash
Lobby Group Seeks Lower Energy Costs for Seniors
Man Dies in New Milford Condo Fire
Stamford Police Find Bomb Materials in Home
Two Motorcyclists Die in Crash on I-91
GE Aviation Buys Czech Turboprop Engine Maker
No Prison Time for Pfizer Employee Embezzlement
State Offering $50K Reward in Milford Homicide
Poll: Rell's Popularity Drops
Man Dies, Son Injured in Voluntown Pond
Regulators Give CL&P OK to Boost Electricity Rates
Union Goes to Court Seeking Permit to Protest
Skier Settles Lawsuit over Steroid Flap
Waterbury's Holy Land Cross Dismantled
Hop Brook Lake CritterCam
Friend of Connecticut poets and writers has died

Due to delays in the WTIC streaming broadcast, listeners to WTIC online
stream may not be able to participate in any WTIC conducted on-air contests.